Maths Olympiad Prep

Track / Stage 6 / 157 of 400 #1157 of 1964

Problem 1157

National Olympiad, first round
Geometry Difficulty 6.1 Prove it

Given that A1、B1、C1A_{1} 、 B_{1} 、 C_{1} are points on the sides BC、CA、ABB C 、 C A 、 A B of the acute triangle △ABC\triangle A B C, and AA1、BB1、CC1A A_{1} 、 B B_{1} 、 C C_{1} are the angle bisectors of ∠BAC、∠CBA、∠ACB\angle B A C 、 \angle C B A 、 \angle A C B respectively, II is the incenter of △ABC\triangle A B C, and HH is the orthocenter of △A1B1C1\triangle A_{1} B_{1} C_{1}. Prove:
AH+BH+CH⩾AI+BI+CI. A H+B H+C H \geqslant A I+B I+C I .

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, then read the official solution and mark yourself. Be honest about it: the record is only any use to you if it is.

Next problem →

Official solution

8. Let's assume
α=∠BAC⩽β=∠CBA⩽γ=∠ACB.  \alpha=\angle B A C \leqslant \beta=\angle C B A \leqslant \gamma=\angle A C B \text {. }

Let the lengths of sides BCBC, CACA, and ABAB of △ABC\triangle ABC be aa, bb, and cc respectively. Let DD and EE be points on side BCBC such that B1D∥ABB_{1} D \parallel AB and B1EB_{1} E bisects ∠BB1C\angle B B_{1} C. Since ∠B1DB=180∘−β\angle B_{1} D B = 180^{\circ} - \beta is an obtuse angle,
⇒BB1>B1D \Rightarrow B B_{1} > B_{1} D
⇒BEEC=BB1B1C>DB1B1C=ABAC=BA1A1C \Rightarrow \frac{B E}{E C} = \frac{B B_{1}}{B_{1} C} > \frac{D B_{1}}{B_{1} C} = \frac{A B}{A C} = \frac{B A_{1}}{A_{1} C}
⇒BE>BA1 \Rightarrow B E > B A_{1}
⇒12∠BB1C=∠BB1E>∠BB1A1. \Rightarrow \frac{1}{2} \angle B B_{1} C = \angle B B_{1} E > \angle B B_{1} A_{1}.
Similarly, 12∠BB1A>∠BB1C1\frac{1}{2} \angle B B_{1} A > \angle B B_{1} C_{1}.
Thus, ∠A1B1C1=∠BB1A1+∠BB1C1\angle A_{1} B_{1} C_{1} = \angle B B_{1} A_{1} + \angle B B_{1} C_{1}
<12(∠BB1C+∠BB1A)=90∘, < \frac{1}{2} \left( \angle B B_{1} C + \angle B B_{1} A \right) = 90^{\circ},

which means ∠A1B1C1\angle A_{1} B_{1} C_{1} is an acute angle.
By symmetry, △A1B1C1\triangle A_{1} B_{1} C_{1} is an acute triangle.
Let BB1B B_{1} intersect A1C1A_{1} C_{1} at point FF.
Since α⩽γ\alpha \leqslant \gamma, we have a⩽ca \leqslant c.
This implies BA1=cab+c⩽aca+b=BC1B A_{1} = \frac{c a}{b + c} \leqslant \frac{a c}{a + b} = B C_{1}.
Thus, ∠BC1A1⩽∠BA1C1\angle B C_{1} A_{1} \leqslant \angle B A_{1} C_{1}.
Since ∠B1FC1=∠BFA1⩽90∘\angle B_{1} F C_{1} = \angle B F A_{1} \leqslant 90^{\circ},
⇒points H and C1 are on the same side of BB1. \Rightarrow \text{points } H \text{ and } C_{1} \text{ are on the same side of } B B_{1}.
Therefore, point HH is inside △BB1C1\triangle B B_{1} C_{1}.
Similarly, since α⩽β⩽γ\alpha \leqslant \beta \leqslant \gamma, point HH is also inside △CC1B1\triangle C C_{1} B_{1} and △AA1C1\triangle A A_{1} C_{1}.
Since α⩽β⩽γ\alpha \leqslant \beta \leqslant \gamma, we have α⩽60∘⩽γ\alpha \leqslant 60^{\circ} \leqslant \gamma.
Thus, ∠BIC⩽120∘⩽∠AIB\angle B I C \leqslant 120^{\circ} \leqslant \angle A I B.
If ∠AIC⩾120∘\angle A I C \geqslant 120^{\circ}, let the rotation transformation with center AA and angle −60∘-60^{\circ} map points BB, II, and HH to points B′B^{\prime}, I′I^{\prime}, and H′H^{\prime}, as shown in Figure 7. Then points B′B^{\prime} and CC are on opposite sides of ABAB.
Since △AI′I\triangle A I^{\prime} I is an equilateral triangle, we have
AI+BI+CI=II′+B′I′+IC=B′I′+I′I+IC. \begin{array}{l} A I + B I + C I = I I^{\prime} + B^{\prime} I^{\prime} + I C \\ = B^{\prime} I^{\prime} + I^{\prime} I + I C. \end{array}

Similarly,
AH+BH+CH=HH′+B′H′+HC=B′H′+H′H+HC.Since ∠AII′=∠AI′I=60∘,∠AI′B′=∠AIB⩾120∘, \begin{array}{c} A H + B H + C H = H H^{\prime} + B^{\prime} H^{\prime} + H C \\ = B^{\prime} H^{\prime} + H^{\prime} H + H C. \\ \text{Since } \angle A I I^{\prime} = \angle A I^{\prime} I = 60^{\circ}, \\ \angle A I^{\prime} B^{\prime} = \angle A I B \geqslant 120^{\circ}, \end{array}

and ∠AIC⩾120∘\angle A I C \geqslant 120^{\circ}, the quadrilateral B′I′ICB^{\prime} I^{\prime} I C is non-concave and on the same side of B′CB^{\prime} C as point AA.

Since point HH is inside △ACC1\triangle A C C_{1}, i.e., outside the quadrilateral B′I′ICB^{\prime} I^{\prime} I C, and HH is also inside △ABI\triangle A B I, point H′H^{\prime} is inside △AB′I′\triangle A B^{\prime} I^{\prime}.
This indicates that point H′H^{\prime} is outside the quadrilateral B′I′ICB^{\prime} I^{\prime} I C.
Thus, the quadrilateral B′I′ICB^{\prime} I^{\prime} I C is inside the quadrilateral B′H′HCB^{\prime} H^{\prime} H C.
From equations (1) and (2), we have
AH+BH+CH⩾AI+BI+CI. A H + B H + C H \geqslant A I + B I + C I.

If ∠AIC<120∘\angle A I C < 120^{\circ}, let the rotation transformation with center CC and angle 60∘60^{\circ} map points BB, II, and HH to points B′B^{\prime}, I′I^{\prime}, and H′H^{\prime}. Then points B′B^{\prime} and AA are on opposite sides of BCBC, and similarly to the case where ∠AIC⩾120∘\angle A I C \geqslant 120^{\circ}, we get
AH+BH+CH⩾AI+BI+CI. A H + B H + C H \geqslant A I + B I + C I.

Source: NuminaMath-1.5, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty, ordering) added by this project.