Maths Olympiad Prep

Track / Stage 6 / 174 of 400 #1174 of 1964

Problem 1174

National Olympiad, first round
Combinatorics Difficulty 6.2 Prove it

Hanging a painting on 4 nails in such a way that if any one of the nails is removed, the painting falls. Is your solution "optimal" (by the way, how would you define an "optimal" solution)?

[!] If you think your solution is optimal, show it.

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, then read the official solution and mark yourself. Be honest about it: the record is only any use to you if it is.

Next problem →

Official solution

An interesting measure of optimality is the number of letters required to write the word associated with the solution. As a solution, one could choose

[[[a1,a2],a3],a4]=a1a2a11a21a3a2a1a21a11a31a4a3a1a2a11a21a31a2a1a21a11a41 \left[\left[\left[a_{1}, a_{2}\right], a_{3}\right], a_{4}\right]=a_{1} a_{2} a_{1}^{-1} a_{2}^{-1} a_{3} a_{2} a_{1} a_{2}^{-1} a_{1}^{-1} a_{3}^{-1} a_{4} a_{3} a_{1} a_{2} a_{1}^{-1} a_{2}^{-1} a_{3}^{-1} a_{2} a_{1} a_{2}^{-1} a_{1}^{-1} a_{4}^{-1}

which contains 22 symbols, but better is

[[a1,a2],[a3,a4]]=a1a2a11a21a3a4a31a41a2a1a21a11a4a3a41a31 \left[\left[a_{1}, a_{2}\right],\left[a_{3}, a_{4}\right]\right]=a_{1} a_{2} a_{1}^{-1} a_{2}^{-1} a_{3} a_{4} a_{3}^{-1} a_{4}^{-1} a_{2} a_{1} a_{2}^{-1} a_{1}^{-1} a_{4} a_{3} a_{4}^{-1} a_{3}^{-1}

which contains only 16.

Source: NuminaMath-1.5, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty, ordering) added by this project.